Re: Official Results Tractor Test 339

[ Manuals Forum ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Kent on May 02, 2008 at 15:37:50 [URL] [DELETE] :

In Reply to: Re: Official Results Tractor Test 339 posted by Jon Rhee (RI) on April 21, 2008 at 13:34:01:

Ah, the miracle of a low compression engine...it could run with no problem on 71 (!) octane fuel.

I doubt there's any appreciable difference in HP with today's higher octane fuel. In fact, there might be a detrimental effect if using 93 (or higher) fuel. Octance number is just a measure of resistance to "knock" or premature ignition of the fuel. When you compress a gas (or in our case an actual gasoline/air mixture), it gets hot. The more you compress, the hotter it gets. With a low octane number, it could get hot enough to ignite without any spark from the plug. If it does that, it almost always not at the right time (or the same time that the plug would ignite it), so a pressure blast hits the top of the piston and side walls of the cylinder, producing "knock".

Today's engines are much higher compression than the N's 6 or 6.5 to 1 ratio (can't remember which). They'd probably almost all 'knock' on that 71 octane gas, especially any of the high-performance engines with compression ratios upwards of twice that of the N. I think there's a practical limit of compression ratio (just the ratio of the volume of the cylinder when the piston is at the low point of its stroke (BDC) compared to the volume of the cylinder when the piston is at the top of its stroke (TDC). Seems like the limit is around 13.5:1. With these high ratios, you compress the mixture even more, so when it ignites and burns, it expands greatly and pushes against the piston with more force. This turns the crankshaft with more force, and the result is more HP. But the flip side of more compression is more heat, and more chance of predetonation, hence the requirement of high performance engines to have 93 octane fuel. Most cars run fine on the 87 (higher altitude) or 89 'regular'. We don't have lead anymore for valve seat lube and anti-knock properties, so they add chemicals to increase the octane number.

A high octane gas is actually harder to ignite than a low octane gas, since it's designed to be more resistant to ignition (to avoid preignition). Thus, you might have a drop in performance with 93 (or sometimes 100 octane gas ocassionally available) gas in the old N that started life as a 6:1 compression ratio and, with years of wear, is probably something even less than that now.


Follow Ups:


Subject:

Posting not permitted in the forum archives.


[ Manuals Forum ] [ FAQ ]